Proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) is a fundamental reaction step of many chemical and biological processes. Well-defined biomimetic systems are promising tools for investigating the PCET mechanisms relevant to natural proteins. Of particular interest is the possibility to distinguish between stepwise and concerted transfer of the electron and proton, and how PCET is controlled by a proton acceptor such as water. Thus, many tyrosine and phenolic derivatives have been shown to undergo either stepwise or concerted PCET, where the latter process is defined by simultaneous tunneling of the electron and proton from the same transition state. For tryptophan instead, it is theoretically predicted that a concerted pathway can never compete with the stepwise electron-first mechanism (ETPT) when neat water is the primary proton acceptor. The argument is based on the radical pKa (∼4.5) that is much higher than that for water (pKa(H3O+) = 0), which thermodynamically disfavors a concerted proton transfer to H2O. This is in contrast to the very acidic radical cation of tyrosine (pKa ∼ -2). However, in this study we show, by direct time-resolved absorption spectroscopy on two [Ru(bpy)3]2+-tryptophan (bpy = 2,2′-bipyridine) analogue complexes, that also tryptophan oxidation with water as a proton acceptor can occur via a concerted pathway, provided that the oxidant has weak enough driving force. This rivals the theoretical predictions and suggests that our current understanding of PCET reactions in water is incomplete. © 2016 American Chemical Society.